Comparison with Temporal, LangGraph, and retries with idempotency keys
This page compares how bide and three other approaches treat side effects across crashes, human approval, audit evidence, and operations. It is scoped to those four questions. It does not rank products, and the others are stronger than bide on several axes that matter in production; those are stated first.
Where the others are stronger
- Temporal has eight SDKs (.NET, Go, Java, PHP, Python, Ruby, Rust and TypeScript) and offers Temporal Cloud as a managed service (why Temporal). Its server scales horizontally; its documentation reports services operating with anywhere from 1 to 128,000 History Shards (Temporal Service). bide is a pre-1.0 Go library with no cluster and no other-language SDKs yet (a wire protocol is designed, not implemented). If you need workers in several languages, a clustered scheduler, or a managed service, Temporal is the stronger choice today.
- LangGraph is available in Python and in JavaScript/TypeScript (LangGraph.js), and its README points to LangSmith for debugging and to a hosted deployment platform for long-running, stateful workflows (LangGraph README). bide has a small set of model adapters (Anthropic, OpenAI-compatible, Gemini), MCP support and bring-your-own retrieval, and Go only. If you work in Python or TypeScript, or want hosted tooling, LangGraph is the stronger choice.
- Plain retries with idempotency keys are the simplest design and need no new runtime. When the downstream API honors idempotency keys, this is often enough, and it is the right answer for many payment integrations. bide does not replace it where the downstream supports keys; the two combine (see below).
- None of this page measures the others' maturity or review history. bide has had no third-party security audit; its guarantees are specified, model-checked within bounds and tested (formal verification), which is not the same as independent review.
Side effects across crashes
| bide | Temporal | LangGraph | Retries + idempotency keys | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Model | Journal with an attempt marker written before a non-idempotent effect; resume replays results | Event History replayed to recreate workflow state; activities are retried under a Retry Policy | Checkpoints of graph state at steps; resume from the last checkpoint | Caller retries; the downstream de-duplicates by key |
| A crash after the effect ran and before its result was recorded | Resume sees a marker with no result and halts with OutcomeUnknown instead of re-running | The activity may run again: Temporal "guarantees that the Activity will be observed as completed exactly once. However, the Activity may be executed multiple times" and recommends idempotent activities (activity definition) | A task that started but did not finish may run again on resume; the docs say to design side effects to be idempotent and use idempotency keys (functional API, idempotency) | Safe only if the downstream honors the key for the whole retry window; otherwise a duplicate |
| Requires the effect to be idempotent | No for the at-most-once path; a tool declared Idempotent or ReadOnly opts out of the halt | Recommended (see quote) | Recommended (see quote) | Yes, that is the mechanism |
| Cost of the guarantee | A halt needs resolution (a person, or a reconciler that queries the provider and calls ResolveHalt). Safety, not liveness | Not compared here | Not compared here | Retries complete automatically; duplicates are the downstream's problem |
The measured result for crash points is in benchmarks/README.md. In the crash-injection benchmark, a non-idempotent charge driven through every seeded crash schedule fired at most once under bide and more than once under every other benchmarked Go SDK. LangGraph (Python, SQLite and Postgres checkpointers, every documented way to write the side effect and every durability mode) re-fired in every configuration it was run in, with its "sync" mode being the most durable. The benchmark did not include Temporal, and a side effect written with an idempotency key would not double-charge in any of them, as the benchmark notes. Method, fairness checks and limits are in that file; the maximum fire count is not a ranking.
Idempotency keys are complementary. bide's at-most-once rests on its own marker, and a key sent to the downstream (as in examples/stripe-refund) covers the case where a human or reconciler decides to retry after a halt. Using both is stronger than either.
Human approval
| bide | Temporal | LangGraph | Plain retries | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pause for a person | Durable gate before the call (WithApproval), or Interrupt inside a tool | Signals and Updates deliver messages to a running Workflow Execution (messages); an approval step is written in workflow code on top of them | interrupt saves the graph state and waits for you to resume with Command(resume=...); it requires a checkpointer (interrupts) | Not provided |
| Multiple approvers | Built-in m-of-n gate; each approver signs the exact call (run, call id, tool, canonical arguments) | Build it in workflow code | Build it in graph code | Not provided |
| Proof that the approval happened before the action | bide audit verify-approvals checks offline that k named approvers signed before the call ran | Not described in the pages cited here (Event History is "a complete and durable log of everything that has happened in the lifecycle of a Workflow Execution", event history) | Not described in the pages cited here | Not provided |
| Binding keys to people | Not provided; your identity provider's job (threat model) | Your auth layer | Your auth layer | Not applicable |
Where bide is limited: a fixed named approver set, no weighted votes or roles, and unsigned recorded_at times (known limitations).
Audit evidence
| bide | Temporal | LangGraph | Plain retries | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Record of what happened | Append-only journal, Merkle-committed (RFC 6962) | Per-execution Event History; closed executions are kept for the Namespace's Retention Period (default 3 days, minimum 1 day, Temporal Service) | Checkpoint history in the checkpointer's store | Application logs |
| Tamper-evidence | Signed tree heads; consistency and absence proofs; verifiable offline by a third party with a public key. Against the operator only when heads are anchored outside their control | Not described in the pages cited here | Not described in the pages cited here | Not applicable |
| Portable evidence for an outside auditor | EvidencePackage, bide audit verify-evidence, stdlib-only verifier | Not compared here | Not compared here | Not applicable |
| Confidentiality | Not provided; leaves are not encrypted | You can apply custom codecs "such as for encryption or compression" to Payloads (data conversion) | Your storage | Your logs |
The cryptographic features are bide's differentiator on this axis; they prove that a record was committed and not altered, not that it is true or that the model reasoned well (threat model).
Operations
| bide | Temporal | LangGraph | Plain retries | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| What you run | Your processes plus SQLite (one machine) or Postgres | The Temporal Service, run yourself or as Temporal Cloud, plus workers | Your processes plus a checkpointer (a durable one in production, per the docs) or the hosted deployment platform | Your services plus a queue or scheduler |
| Scale | Many concurrent durable runs per process; nodes coordinate through Postgres leases. Not benchmarked against a cluster scheduler | Horizontally scalable services; see the History Shard figures above | Not compared here | Depends on deployment |
| Version status | Pre-1.0; formats may change between releases (stability) | Not compared here | Not compared here | Not applicable |
| Languages | Go only | Eight SDKs (see above) | Python, JavaScript/TypeScript | Any |
| Recovery of dead holders | RecoverLoop and leases; the attempt claim, not the lease, keeps effects at most once | Workflow replay recreates state after a failure (Event History docs) | Resume from a checkpoint with the same thread ID (interrupts docs) | Queue redelivery |
| Observability | OTel spans (trace.Instrument), bide view | Not compared here | LangSmith (README) | Your tooling |
Choosing
- Money moves, the downstream has no idempotency key, and an auditor will ask you to prove what happened: bide fits, accepting a pre-1.0 Go library and the cost of resolving halts.
- The downstream honors idempotency keys and you need polyglot workers or very large scale: Temporal, or plain retries with keys, is the better fit; bide's audit layer is not available there.
- A Python prototype against many providers: LangGraph. Treat side effects as at-least-once and use idempotency keys.
Sources: bide's guarantee and benchmarks; the Temporal and LangGraph pages linked above, read on 2026-10-13. Quoted text is theirs; statements about what a page does not describe mean this page did not find it in the pages cited, not that the product lacks it. Their products change; check their current documentation. If something here is wrong, please open an issue and it will be corrected.